Both were sentenced to life imprisonment for the rape of the girl and subsequently sentenced to 35 years for engaging in a child exploitation enterprise. Falte had been an administrator on The GiftBox Exchange, another darknet child exploitation site that was shut down in November 2016. Benjamin Faulkner's associate, Patrick Falte, was captured together with Faulkner when they met in Virginia in October 2016 two days after they had raped a four-year-old girl.The capture of the site, and its subsequent use to gather information, has led to arrests and convictions: James Sheptycki, professor in criminology at York University, criticized the transfer of the website from its original server in Europe to Australia as ' jurisdiction shopping', being done due to the favourable legal framework in Australia that would allow the website to continue running in this way. ECPAT (End Child Prostitution, Child Pornography and Trafficking of Children for Sexual Purposes) supported the proactive approach taken by Task Force Argos. Amnesty International also criticized the actions as 'unacceptable under human rights law'. Ivar Stokkereit, a legal adviser to the United Nations Children's Fund ( UNICEF) in Norway, stated this was 'a clear violation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, even though the police’s intention is to prevent new offenses in the long run'. The website was run by Australian police for 11 months, and involved impersonation of the forum owner WarHead (Faulkner's alias) which required police to regularly post child abuse images, in order to convince users that the site was not compromised.

Tor links young porn